Forensic Accounting

Family Business Disputes in the UAE: The Financial Side of Succession and Buyouts

Family business disputes in the UAE are rarely arguments about the law. They are arguments about numbers that were never properly recorded: personal expenses paid by the company, drawings that no one documented as either salary or loan, and a business whose value nobody has independently established. The legal framework, Federal Decree-Law No. 37 of 2022 on Family Businesses and Federal Decree-Law No. 32 of 2021 on Commercial Companies, sets out how ownership and governance work. It does not tell you what the shares are worth, and that is usually the question the family cannot answer among itself.

The Records Are the Dispute

In a company built by one generation and inherited by the next, the accounting typically reflects how the founder actually ran it rather than how a third party would read it. That is not necessarily wrongdoing. It becomes a dispute when a second generation, or an exiting sibling, asks what belongs to whom.

Four patterns produce most of the conflict. Personal and company accounts that were never separated, so property, vehicles, school fees, and travel sit in the company's books. Drawings taken by family members over years with no board resolution and no loan agreement, leaving no basis to say whether they were remuneration, dividends, or debt. Assets held in a family member's personal name but paid for and maintained by the company. And informal arrangements, a promised share or an agreed salary, recorded nowhere.

None of these can be resolved by argument, because each side remembers the arrangement differently and both may be sincere. They are resolved by reconstruction from the documents that do exist.

Undocumented Drawings and Loans

The recurring question is how to characterise money that family members took out. The characterisation matters because it changes the answer: remuneration is an expense and reduces the profit everyone shares, a dividend is a distribution that should have been proportionate to holdings, and a loan is repayable and sits as an asset of the company.

Where no resolution or agreement exists, the analysis works from what was actually done. Was the amount regular and consistent with a salary, or irregular and matched to personal needs. Was tax or end-of-service treated as if it were remuneration. Was it recorded to a director's current account and, if so, was that account ever reconciled or repaid. Did other shareholders receive an equivalent amount at the same time, which would suggest a distribution.

The output is not a legal conclusion. It is a schedule showing, for each family member, what was taken, when, and how it was treated in the books, which allows the court or the family to characterise it on a common set of facts.

Assets held personally but funded by the company raise the same question in reverse. A property registered to one family member and paid for from company funds is either that member's asset with a corresponding debt to the company, or a company asset held through a nominee. The accounting evidence is the same in both cases: the source of the purchase funds, who paid the running costs, and where the rental income or benefit went. The characterisation is for the court, but it cannot be argued without that schedule.

Valuation for a Buyout

Most family disputes end in someone being bought out, and the price is where the settlement usually fails. The difficulty is that the two sides are valuing different things: the departing member values a share of a business as it might be, and the continuing members value a business as it will be once its founder's personal goodwill and unpaid contribution are stripped out.

A defensible valuation states its basis explicitly: whether it is an asset-based, income-based, or market-based approach, why that approach fits this business, what normalisation adjustments have been made to remove personal expenses and non-commercial related-party pricing, and what discount, if any, applies to a minority holding. An unstated basis is the most common reason a family valuation collapses under scrutiny.

Normalisation is usually the contested part. Adding back the founder's personal expenses raises the profit and therefore the price, while adjusting for an under-market salary the founder never drew lowers it. Both are legitimate; doing one without the other is not.

Minority holdings deserve their own note, because the discount applied to them is often the single largest adjustment in the calculation and the least explained. A minority shareholder cannot compel a dividend, force a sale, or control the board, and a valuation that ignores that overstates what the holding is worth to a buyer. Equally, a discount applied mechanically at a conventional percentage, without reference to what this shareholder can actually do under the constitutional documents, is an assertion rather than a valuation. The governing documents decide it, not convention.

The Family Charter

Federal Decree-Law No. 37 of 2022 on Family Businesses provides a framework for governing family-owned companies, and provides the framework for the family charter as an instrument for regulating ownership, succession, and the transfer of shares. Federal Decree-Law No. 32 of 2021 on Commercial Companies governs the company itself.

A charter is worth more before a dispute than during one, and its financial provisions are the ones that do the work: a stated valuation methodology, an agreed process for appointing a valuer, pre-emption terms, and a rule on whether family members drawing from the company are treated as employees, shareholders, or borrowers. A charter that settles governance but leaves valuation to be agreed later has deferred the exact question that causes the litigation.

Why a Court Expert's Number Is Often the Only One Accepted

Where the family has already tried and failed to agree, each side has usually commissioned its own valuation and each rejects the other's. A court-appointed expert breaks that deadlock for a structural reason rather than a technical one: the expert is instructed by the court under Part 10 of Federal Decree-Law No. 35 of 2022 on Evidence, Articles 109 to 125, answers to the court alone, and has no commercial relationship with either branch of the family.

The expert also has access neither side will give the other. Article 115 entitles the expert to request the company's books, records, and documents, and Article 116 refers a refusal back to the court, which matters when one branch controls the accounting system and the other has been outside it for years.

Families frequently reach settlement once the court expert's figure exists, without waiting for judgment. The number ceases to be an argument between relatives and becomes an independent fact both can accept without either conceding to the other, which in a family matter is often the real obstacle.

Timing matters as much as method. A valuation date fixed at the point of the disagreement produces a different figure from one fixed at the date of judgment, particularly where the business has continued to trade under one branch's control while the dispute ran. Agreeing the valuation date early removes an argument that otherwise arrives after the work is done and can require it to be redone.

What to Do Before It Becomes a Dispute

Separate the accounts, document the drawings as one thing or another, formalise assets held personally but funded by the company, and agree the valuation methodology while everyone is still on speaking terms. None of this is expensive compared to a contested valuation, and all of it is easier to do before positions harden.

How AABDxb Helps

AABDxb prepares business valuations and financial analysis for UAE family business disputes, including reconstruction of undocumented drawings, separation of personal and company transactions, and valuation for buyouts. The firm is led by a Ministry of Justice registered court-appointed accounting expert, so the analysis is built to the standard a court applies whether or not the matter ends up in front of one.

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

How are undocumented family drawings treated in a UAE company dispute?

The question is how to characterise them, because the characterisation changes the outcome: remuneration is an expense that reduces shared profit, a dividend is a distribution that should have been proportionate to holdings, and a loan is repayable and remains an asset of the company. Where no board resolution or loan agreement exists, the analysis works from what was actually done: whether the amounts were regular and salary-like, whether they were recorded to a director's current account and ever reconciled, and whether other shareholders received an equivalent amount at the same time. The output is a schedule of what was taken and how it was treated, not a legal conclusion.

How is a UAE family business valued for a buyout?

A defensible valuation states its basis explicitly: whether it uses an asset-based, income-based, or market-based approach and why that approach fits the business; what normalisation adjustments remove personal expenses and non-commercial related-party pricing; and what discount, if any, applies to a minority holding. Normalisation is usually the contested part, because adding back the founder's personal expenses raises the price while adjusting for an under-market salary the founder never drew lowers it. Both adjustments are legitimate, and doing one without the other is not.

Why do families accept a court expert's valuation when they reject each other's?

For a structural reason rather than a technical one. A court-appointed expert is instructed by the court under Part 10 of Federal Decree-Law No. 35 of 2022, Articles 109 to 125, answers to the court alone, and has no commercial relationship with either side of the family. The expert also has access neither branch will give the other: Article 115 entitles the expert to request the company's books and records, and Article 116 refers a refusal back to the court. Families often settle once that figure exists, because the number becomes an independent fact rather than a concession to a relative.

Our family business is in a dispute after the founder died. Who can examine the accounts?

An independent accounting expert, instructed by the heirs jointly where possible, otherwise by one side through a lawyer or appointed by the court. The examination establishes what the company owned and owed at the date of death, what each family member drew before and after it, which drawings were salary, dividend or loan, and what the business is worth for any division or buyout. Where the founder kept records informally, the expert reconstructs them from bank statements and contracts and states clearly what could and could not be established. A report prepared this way gives the heirs one set of figures to negotiate from, and the court a reasoned basis if they cannot agree.

Continue Reading

Explore more articles on UAE financial disputes, audit, and expert reports.

Add AABDxb as a preferred source on Google